Theories and the Rise of Sapiens

Why we crave Bad News and how it connects to Sustainability? Yuval Noah Harari’s “Sapiens – A Brief History of Humankind” introduces two compelling (but possibly complementary) theories about human evolution, shedding light on our social and cognitive development:

The “There-is-a-lion-near-the-river” Theory: This theory emphasizes the importance of sharing critical information about the physical environment. Early humans relied on communication to warn others about dangers such as predators or to pinpoint resources like food and water. It suggests that language evolved primarily for conveying practical, survival-related information.

Gossip Theory: In contrast, this theory posits that language evolved primarily for social cohesion. Gossip played a crucial role in shaping social dynamics by sharing information about trustworthiness, hunting prowess, or potential threats. It suggests that language emerged to discuss and navigate complex social relationships, beyond merely conveying factual information.

Both theories offer valuable insights into the development of Homo Sapiens:

  • Enhanced Information Sharing: Effective communication, regardless of content, facilitated the transfer of knowledge and experiences across generations. This exchange of information was pivotal in developing tools, strategies, and cultural practices essential for survival and adaptation.
  • Collective Intelligence: The ability to share information fostered collaboration and problem-solving, requiring abstract thinking and collective intelligence unique to humans.
  • The Power of Symbols: Language, as a system of symbols, allowed early humans to represent abstract concepts, laying the groundwork for symbolic thought—a hallmark of sapience.
  • Social Learning and Culture: Gossip not only transmitted information but also social norms and values, shaping cultural practices and fostering group identity—a crucial factor in the development of complex societies.

Why Negative News Prevails

In his thought-provoking book, Yuval Noah Harari introduces us to the ideas that shed light on the human propensity for exchanging information about others and our inherent bias towards negative news. But what does this tell us about our relationship with sustainability?

From the earliest days of our existence, humans have been wired to pay attention to negative information. It’s a survival mechanism ingrained in our psyche. Millennia ago, our ancestors had to be hyper-aware of potential threats like predators lurking nearby—a mindset encapsulated in the metaphorical image of a lion near the river. In today’s world, this negativity bias manifests in our fascination with doom-and-gloom news stories.

The Role of Gossip 

Gossip isn’t merely idle chatter; it serves vital functions in society. It helps us bond with others, transmit cultural norms, and manage reputations. However, gossip can also perpetuate stereotypes and misinformation. In the age of social media, gossip spreads faster than ever, often amplifying negative narratives. The echo chambers created by social media algorithms can exacerbate negativity bias. 

Linking to Sustainability

The idea that information sharing is vital for survival can be directly applied to sustainability. Just like the “lion” warning, sharing information about environmental threats like pollution or dwindling resources can be crucial for motivating change.

However, consider the media’s portrayal of environmental issues. Sensationalist reporting often paints a bleak picture of the future, focusing on catastrophic events and impending disasters. While these stories are undeniably important, they can also evoke feelings of hopelessness and apathy, hindering our collective efforts towards sustainability. We can do it differently. By understanding the evolutionary roots of gossip and reframing it as a tool for sharing important information, we can promote sustainable practices and build a culture of environmental awareness.

How We Can Shift the Narrative

Just as gossip can shape perceptions, it can also be harnessed to promote positive change. We must strive to balance our consumption of negative news with stories of progress, innovation, and resilience. Highlighting successful sustainability initiatives, showcasing inspiring individuals, and sharing actionable solutions can empower us to envision—and create—a brighter future.

As we navigate the complexities of our world, let’s remember the power of storytelling. By reframing the narrative around sustainability, we can transcend the limitations of our negativity bias and inspire meaningful action. Together, let’s gossip about a future where sustainability thrives—a future worth sharing. 

Share your thoughts!